HomeArchivesSpeakingAudio / Video The ExchangeLifeWay ResearchLifeWay Research Team
Home
Home
FacebookRSSTwitterVimeoYouTube
Click here to have Ed's RSS feed on your site
Topics
  • Articles
  • Bible
  • Blog
  • Books
  • Church
  • Church Planting
  • Church Revitalization
  • Culture
  • Humor
  • International Missions
  • Interviews
  • Leaders
  • Lifeway
  • Megachurch
  • Ministry
  • Missional
  • Multisite
  • Personal
  • Politics
  • Preaching
  • Presentations
  • Research
  • SBC
  • Seminars
  • Social Media
  • Teaching
  • Theology
  • Video
  • Web
Series
  • Guide to the Blog
  • The Meanings of Missional (5 Parts)
  • Multi-site Churches
  • Young Adult Dropouts
  • Calvinism and the SBC
Leadership Interview
  • Thom and Sam Rainer: Essential Church
  • Brad Waggoner: The Shape Of Faith To Come
  • Jared Wilson: Your Jesus is Too Safe
  • Tullian Tchividjian: Unfashionable
  • Skye Jethani: The Divine Commodity
  • Mark Liederbach & Alvin L. Reid: The Convergent Church
  • Scott McConnell: Multi-Site Churches w/ Scott McConnell
  • Steve Ogne & Tim Roeh: TransforMissional Coaching
  • Alan Hirsch & Michael Frost: ReJesus
  • Kary Oberbrunner: The Fine Line
  • Steve Addison: Movements That Change The World
  • John Avant: If God Were Real
  • Geoff Surratt: Ten Stupid Things That Keep Churches from Growing
Most Popular Posts
  • Thinking on the Plane
  • Reflecting on Balance and Rest in the Ministry
  • My Interview with Adrian Warnock: Why We Need Non-Paid Christian Leaders
  • Thursday is for Thinkers: Wendy Horger Alsup on Equipping Women for Gospel-Centered Lives
  • No Such Thing as "the Gift of Evangelism"
  • Comment Policy
  • Church Leadership Book Interview: Charles Stone on 5 Ministry Killers and How to Defeat Them
  • Transformational Church
  • Viral Churches Interview
  • Christians are Hate-Filled Hypocrites . . . and Other Lies You've Been Told
Alltop - Best of the Best
 

Contextualization, Fundamentalists, Modernists, the ABWE, and the Kingdom

Monday May 19, 2008   ~   10 Comments

I had an interesting and exciting week last week at two mission boards.

First, it was good to connect with theologically conservative and biblically driven people who care about contextualization-- at the International Mission Board and the Association of Baptists for Worldwide Evangelism.

Right now, there is a backlash against contextualization in some quarters of evangelicalism. This is unfortunate-- evangelicals do not need more reasons not to engage culture. They can be, as I often say, "biblically faithful, culturally relevant, counter culture communities for the gospel and the Kingdom." Missionaries get that... and I love being around them.

For example, the folks at the Association of Baptists for Worldwide Evangelization (the ABWE), have a great resource to help people determine the "soil" they are seeking to reach. You can see the seminar here. They understand that the "how of evangelism is in many ways determined by the 'who, when, and where' of culture."

Second, my transportation got my blood flowing. The good folks at the ABWE sent a plane to get me-- a really small plane. And, I must confess to being a bit nervous due to the weather.

My favorite moment was when my "pilot" introduced me to the young man who was flying the plane. He was 18 years of age. He did great... under the guidance of his flight instructor. And, I was able to get a good night of sleep thanks to their help.

Third, it was good to review some history over dinner with ABWE President Michael Loftis. The ABWE was founded by missionaries from the American Baptist mission board. And their founding got me thinking about the Fundamentalist - Modernist Controversy.

The early twentieth century was a time of theological conflict between churches. Every denomination was impacted. One of the prominent battles took place in the 1920's and 30's within the Presbyterian Church of the United States of America.

The "Fundamentalist-Modernist Controversy�? was a clash between theologies typified by Harry Emerson Fosdick on one end (liberal), and J. Gresham Machen (classic fundamentalism) on the other. Before the term fundamentalism became associated with cultural retreat it was primarily a theological term that pointed to five essential doctrines common to fundamentalists: the inspiration and inerrancy of Scripture, the virgin birth, vicarious penal atonement, and bodily resurrection of Jesus Christ, and the historical reality of his miracles. The controversy surrounding these and related doctrines were not superficial, but critical to the identity and action of the church.

Theology gives birth to action, and differences in doctrine lead to differences in practice. For example, some of those who held more liberal theology often saw the Kingdom of God as that which would ultimately come about through the restorative, social outworking of gospel principles by "God's grace in human life and institutions.�? (I recently gave some cautions regarding this view at the dwell conference in NYC.)

For many liberals the coming of Christ was not an external arrival of the Savior, but his gradual emergence through the church's social work. Classic fundamentalist theology saw the Kingdom of God as that which is established by the life, death and resurrection of Jesus Christ, entered into by faith and repentance, and culminates in the literal return of Jesus Christ. Some churches found their primary ministry in social work, while other churches saw their primary goal to be evangelism and church planting, and it was differing views of the gospel and the kingdom that led to these differences.

That difference became a point of contention in the ministry of Dr. Raphael Thomas (as explained in the ABWE history document here):

Dr. Thomas had a great heart and gift for evangelism. He loved to travel into the countryside, visiting the barrios, ministering to souls as well as bodies. He also had a real rapport with high school and college students in Iloilo and developed ministries to reach them with the gospel of Jesus Christ. These activities became a point of conflict when he was criticized by fellow workers for not spending enough time in the hospital. Complaints were made against him to the board. Finally, orders came from the general secretary of the home board telling Dr. Thomas to cease his evangelistic itineration and confine himself to running the hospital. This he could not conscientiously do. It was intolerable that he not be permitted to carry out his first love, evangelism, which was the primary reason for his presence in the Philippines. He felt that he could not continue under that yoke.

Dr. Thomas and his family returned to the USA in February of 1927 and resigned from the ABFMS soon afterwards. In August of that year, they visited the home of Marguerite Doane, along with several other friends. That informal get-together resulted in the birth of the Association of Baptists for World Evangelism (ABWE), with the Thomases as one of the founders and its first missionaries. They returned to the Philippines in 1928 where they ministered for several more years. Dr. Thomas retired from the mission field shortly before the outbreak of World War 2, but continued in active service for the mission as a traveling national representative for a number of years.

Those of us who believe the "Kingdom of God" is an important emphasis (that needs to be reclaimed) must be careful. It would be a tragedy if we failed to learn that the last group that used the Kingdom of God to talk of justice often forgot to talk of Jesus. The folks at the ABWE believe we can do both-- and I agree with them.

Posted on May 19, 2008 at 8:52 AM   ~   10 Comments

Tagged with: abwe, church, history, imb, mission boards

Subscribe via RSS or Follow us on Twitter
Follow us via RSS Follow us On Twitter

Share This Post
Facebook
del.icio.us
StumbleUpon
Digg
TwitThis
Mixx
Technorati
NewsVine
Reddit
Google
LinkedIn
co.mments
YahooMyWeb

10 Comments

By David Phillips on May 19, 2008 9:55 AM

Ok, since you didn't say, I pray to God it was the D-Jet that they flew you around on...Those others were downright scary.

By Chuck Bryce on May 19, 2008 10:51 AM

Anxiously awaiting your next survey. Now taking odds there will be an airplane illustration in it.

By Ed Stetzer on May 19, 2008 11:07 AM

Oh, David, how I wish it was. It was actually the 4 seater with the small propeller. See here.

By M. Steve Heartsill on May 19, 2008 2:09 PM

After seeing the picture of the plane, if anyone ever doubts that you are a man of great faith, just whip out that picture and show them!

You are a brave man Ed!

Hope the crop dusting went well as they dropped you off.

By Larry on May 19, 2008 7:29 PM

What a cool plane!!

Wish I would have been with you!

By Ed Stetzer on May 19, 2008 9:37 PM

Larry, if you were there it would be full... 4 seats.

By Michael on May 20, 2008 9:04 AM

wow, was the pilot wearing a leather helmet, goggles and a scarf?

By Park HyungWoo on May 20, 2008 10:38 AM

It's cool!
I read your excellent book, "Comeback Churches".
I want to translate English from into Korean.
Could you allow that?
Let't me know about that.

By Mike Watkins on May 20, 2008 5:08 PM

This is a very insightful post, and it is more important than most would think. In order for us to truly reach the world around us we need to employ all the troops, all the reserves, even those who have found reason not to engage the culture around us.

Unfortunately, the modern fundamentalist has been spooked by those who have abandoned orthodoxy at the expense of growth and who also use the same “missional� language. Keep up the great communication on your end.

On a side note I am enjoying your book, Planting Missional Churches. As an overseas missionary it communicates very clearly my experiences and gives me new insights and ideas. Thanks.

By Dave Miller on May 20, 2008 6:07 PM

I participated in a Lifeway survey and they sent me a book called "Comeback Churches" by some man named Stetzer in response.

Was that meant as a reward or a punishment by Lifeway?

Comment Policy

Comments are welcome on discussion posts.  Comments are not moderated but do require a keyword to avoid spam.  If this is your first time commenting, please review the comment policy.

Leave a comment

» Subscribe to these comments.
 
Recent Comments
  • Dave Miller commented on Contextualization, Fundamentalists, Modernists, the ABWE, and the Kingdom.
  • Mike Watkins commented on Contextualization, Fundamentalists, Modernists, the ABWE, and the Kingdom.
  • Park HyungWoo commented on Contextualization, Fundamentalists, Modernists, the ABWE, and the Kingdom.
  • Michael commented on Contextualization, Fundamentalists, Modernists, the ABWE, and the Kingdom.
  • Ed Stetzer commented on Contextualization, Fundamentalists, Modernists, the ABWE, and the Kingdom.
  • Larry commented on Contextualization, Fundamentalists, Modernists, the ABWE, and the Kingdom.
Twitter Feed
    My Books
    Compelled by Love Comeback Churches   Breaking the missional Code
    Planting Missional Churches 11 Innocations in the Local Church   Spiritual Warfare and Missions
    Mission Shift Lost and Found   Viral Churches
    Small Group Resources

    Install Flash

    Get Adobe Flash player

    Schools Where I Teach
    Compelled by Love
    Ministry Partnerships
    Christianity Today Outreach magazine
    Catalyst Monthly Facts and Trends
    Christian Post
    imb connecting Baptist Center
    LifeWay: Research - Biblical Solutions for Life
    LifeWay: Biblical Solutions for Life
    Noteworthy Items
    Noteworthy Items
    • Thabiti for the Gospel
    • Theology and Worship with Mike Cosper
    • What Berger said
    • Ed Stetzer on How Leaders Are Vital to Church Transformation
    • Innovative or Innovation Dysfunctional
    • Star Wars on the Subway
    • TOAM10 Audio now available
    • One Key to Social Media Success