HomeArchivesSpeakingAudio / Video The ExchangeLifeWay ResearchLifeWay Research Team
Home
Home
FacebookRSSTwitterVimeoYouTube
Click here to have Ed's RSS feed on your site
Topics
  • Articles
  • Bible
  • Blog
  • Books
  • Church
  • Church Planting
  • Church Revitalization
  • Culture
  • Humor
  • International Missions
  • Interviews
  • Leaders
  • Lifeway
  • Megachurch
  • Ministry
  • Missional
  • Multisite
  • Personal
  • Politics
  • Preaching
  • Presentations
  • Research
  • SBC
  • Seminars
  • Social Media
  • Teaching
  • Theology
  • Video
  • Web
Series
  • Guide to the Blog
  • The Meanings of Missional (5 Parts)
  • Multi-site Churches
  • Young Adult Dropouts
  • Calvinism and the SBC
Leadership Interview
  • Thom and Sam Rainer: Essential Church
  • Brad Waggoner: The Shape Of Faith To Come
  • Jared Wilson: Your Jesus is Too Safe
  • Tullian Tchividjian: Unfashionable
  • Skye Jethani: The Divine Commodity
  • Mark Liederbach & Alvin L. Reid: The Convergent Church
  • Scott McConnell: Multi-Site Churches w/ Scott McConnell
  • Steve Ogne & Tim Roeh: TransforMissional Coaching
  • Alan Hirsch & Michael Frost: ReJesus
  • Kary Oberbrunner: The Fine Line
  • Steve Addison: Movements That Change The World
  • John Avant: If God Were Real
  • Geoff Surratt: Ten Stupid Things That Keep Churches from Growing
Most Popular Posts
  • Missional Weddings?
  • Book Interview: Ten Stupid Things That Keep Churches from Growing
  • Leadership Book Interview: The Strategically Small Church by Brandon O'Brien
  • When Missional Churches Will Multiply
  • My Interview with Adrian Warnock: Why We Need Non-Paid Christian Leaders
  • Thursday is for Thinkers: Rice Broocks on The Evangelist and the Missional Church
  • The Exchange All Day: Transformational Small Churches
  • Thursday is for Thinkers: Jason Hayes on Mentoring
  • Down Time at Glorieta
  • SBC 2008 Monday
Alltop - Best of the Best
 

Younger & Ethnic Leaders in Denominations

Thursday January 21, 2010   ~   14 Comments

I have been a vocal advocate of the need for more younger and more ethnic leaders in denominational leadership. I have written and spoken on it many times in my own denomination and in several others.

It is on my mind again.

I spent Monday and Tuesday with the leadership of the Foursquare Church Cabinet. Although there are major polity differences, it would have some things in common with the SBC's Executive Committee, the Assemblies of God Executive Presbytery, or the Evangelical Free Church's Board of Directors.

I was there helping them through some facilitated conversations around their identity and their presidential search process. It was a good meeting. But, while there, I was struck by the number of young and ethnic leaders. Several mentioned that they had implemented a new plan to create broader representation. I asked my friend, Rod Koop, to tell me how they did this.

Rod is the "Missional Facilitator" for the Foursquare and here is what he wrote me:


We noted the lack of of this representation at past cabinet meetings, and this corresponded to some young leaders who told us they were feeling a lack of value in terms of their input.


The steps we took to address this were:
- The Board made a decision to expand this year's Cabinet by 28 members. Two new representatives from each district, one would be an "Elder" and one would be a "Younger" leader.
- Each of our fourteen districts has an Advisory Council. These groups then nominated three leaders for each of these two categories.
- At the National Church Office, we created ballots for each individual district. These ballots contained three names of "Elder" leaders, and three names of "Younger" leaders.
- These ballots were sent to all licensed ministers in each district with the instructions to select one from each category.
- Those that were elected were added to this year's cabinet meeting.


It seems to have worked to bring together different generations in an impressive mix of ages. (Jack Hayford said he was the oldest person in the room and one young leader was a brand new pastor.) And, they worked well together-- combining wisdom of decades with fresh new eyes.

Also there was strong ethnic participation. Ted Vail oversees the Urban/Multicultural Dept. As part of his team, Ted has an advisory group of nine leaders who make up his "Multicultural Committee." (Hispanic, Brazilian, African/American, Chinese, Korean, Japanese and Native American). Every one of these leaders is extended a special invitation by the Board to fully participate in these Cabinet meetings. Their voices were heard.

Rod wrote:

During our meetings, one of our younger, Latino leaders (who also happens to be from Florida and is leading that district's Haiti Disaster Relief efforts), mentioned how much they appreciated seeing so many faces in the room like their own. THAT'S what we're after.


If you are a predominantly Anglo (and older) denomination, you cannot, AND WILL NOT, expand the leadership base to younger, ethnic, and African-American leaders without an intentional plan. Why? Because we elect or appoint to leadership those who we know. And the people we know tend to look like us.

Simply put, denominations will not embrace young and ethnic leaders without a plan and a strategy to do so.

The Foursquare Church has a different polity than many denominations (including my own). But, that is no excuse for inaction. You and your denomination need a plan.

If you are in a denomination, what is yours doing? What should it do?

Posted on January 21, 2010 at 9:05 AM   ~   14 Comments

Tagged with:

Subscribe via RSS or Follow us on Twitter
Follow us via RSS Follow us On Twitter

Share This Post
Facebook
del.icio.us
StumbleUpon
Digg
TwitThis
Mixx
Technorati
NewsVine
Reddit
Google
LinkedIn
co.mments
YahooMyWeb

14 Comments

By Adam Shields on January 21, 2010 8:42 AM

Great job Foursquare! Thanks for passing on their ideas Ed. I am on the verge of not being a younger any more. And the older I get the more I think that younger need to pay attention to wisdom of the older, but the only way to do that in a healthy way is to make sure that the younger and the older are interacting. I hear lots of complaints that minority and young aren't coming to meetings, but often there are two issues. One is that many younger and minority don't have time or money to come. Second, many of the meetings deal with things that younger and minority just aren't interested in. Have to deal with both problems, not just one or other.

By Chris Chavez on January 21, 2010 9:23 AM

I could not agree more. The 'Rooney Rule' in the NFL ensures minority candidates get an interview for coaching jobs. I once heard a pastor say they were intentionally trying to diversify their staff. He said he wanted to be an example to his flock that were business owners because how could he expect them to get it unless they see leadership paving the way.

With no plan in place, there is only rhetoric about how awesome it would be reflect the diversity found in the body of Christ. Step 1: How awesome would it be to have a plan.

By Ed StetzerAuthor Profile Page on January 21, 2010 9:25 AM

Adam, I used to be young once too. ;-)

Chavez,

Good to hear from you. Praying for you guys. Thanks for the good word.

Ed

By Tom Scott on January 21, 2010 9:47 AM

I so appreciate you Ed. You have a wonderful platform to communicate such powerful messages and I pray God will always lead your steps. Thanks for this important message today about our future.

Gratefully,
Tom

By Ryan on January 21, 2010 10:38 AM

Here's something else Foursquare is doing to proactively engage and release young leaders. http://www.emergingleadernetwork.com/ What is going on in our cabinet and leadership is awesome. How those changes materialize on every level of leadership will ultimately determine the lifespan of this denomination.

This is true of every church, organization and denomination. To be viable now and in the future, great emphasis must be placed on recognizing and releasing a diverse mix of leaders, young and old, from all backgrounds and ethnicities. If leadership is held tightly by a few who all think, talk and dress the same, the flow of leaders will bottleneck. And as many of us have seen or experienced, leaders who are not recognized and released in a healthy, timely way, will give up or move on to find other places to lead.

By Tom Cho on January 22, 2010 2:17 AM

thanks ed. i applaud you pointing this out. for some reason, this often gets neglected. Rah's book is very helpful, and his discussion on the emergent movement is alarming. Why are so few non-whites on panels/conferences? Why is this issue so sorely neglected? The HUP needs to die a quick death. The only thing I would like to point out to you is the use of the word "ethnic". White churches are ethnic also, just "ethnically" e.g. western european. The word "ethnic" should be used as a synonym for non-white. I think the goal is a Multi-ethnic church that includes whites, asians, black, etc with leadership both in local churches and presbyteries, denominations etc that reflect that. Thanks again Ed.

By Ed StetzerAuthor Profile Page on January 22, 2010 8:08 AM

Tom,

Thanks.

In regards to ethnics, the word is actually used in both ways depending on the literature. In the social sciences, it usually refers to those who see themselves (and are considered by the larger society) as distinct by their culture or other factors.

Either way, we just don't want a bunch of predominantly Anglo denominations thinking they don't need to be more ethnic because they already are. ;-)

God bless,

Ed

By tom on January 22, 2010 8:18 AM

i understand that it's the way it's used. as a minority I can tell you that it's offensive. actually i think it's helpful for majority cultures to see themselves as ethnic as well. Many of my friends who are also "ethnic" also find this use of language offensive.

By Ed StetzerAuthor Profile Page on January 22, 2010 8:19 AM

Thanks, Tom.

By Chuck on January 22, 2010 8:45 AM

I've been working on the website for "MainLine Call" (http://mainlinecall.org) so I found this entry quite timely.

The point I'd like to see you pursue is not so much how to integrate new young and ethnic leaders so much (as important) as that might be, but how to recruit young leaders for the work of Church Revitalization.

I hope you'll address that too!

By Rob Peters on January 22, 2010 10:22 AM

Ed, this is who first baptist church weston, fl is. that is why i wanted to get you down here to see and interact with our people. we have over 60 nationalities in our church and over 50 young people entering full-time christian ministry. want to take a look at what this looks like on a local church level. check out fbcweston.org

By aarron schwartz on January 23, 2010 4:24 PM

I think one of the simple reasons the SBC has a problem getting younger leadership is that they are more concerned with self preservation and duplication than re-creation. They bring younger leaders to the table only to give them advice or get them involved in something already established by the status quo. It seems to be the "Hey look, we got one!" approach rather than really allowing younger people to lead. It simply becomes a re-packaging of old ideas. I have talked to 3 different gifted leaders who grew up in our denom. and feel called to plant but wont do it with the SBC because they dont feel that their vision and ideas are welcome... sad.

By Sam on January 30, 2010 1:19 PM

Thanks Ed, for joining our Foursquare conversation. Hopefully some of the innovations we are utilizing in the presidential selection process will translate broadly throughout the organization. We are contending for more women in senior leadership, younger pastors, and broad ethnic representation, not for the purpose of being politically correct or diverse for its own sake, but to better serve God and the needs of harvest.

By sam on January 30, 2010 1:25 PM

Thanks Ed, for joining the Foursquare conversation. I am hopeful that innovations in the context of the presidenital selection process will translate broadly thorughout our organization. It is my desire that we multiply women, youth, and ethnic reps in senior pastoral leadership in Foursquare, not to be politically correct or diverse for its own sake but to better serve God and the needs of the harvest.

Comment Policy

Comments are welcome on discussion posts.  Comments are not moderated but do require a keyword to avoid spam.  If this is your first time commenting, please review the comment policy.

Leave a comment

» Subscribe to these comments.
 
Recent Comments
  • sam commented on Younger & Ethnic Leaders in Denominations.
  • Sam commented on Younger & Ethnic Leaders in Denominations.
  • aarron schwartz commented on Younger & Ethnic Leaders in Denominations.
  • Rob Peters commented on Younger & Ethnic Leaders in Denominations.
  • Chuck commented on Younger & Ethnic Leaders in Denominations.
  • Ed Stetzer commented on Younger & Ethnic Leaders in Denominations.
Twitter Feed
    My Books
    Compelled by Love Comeback Churches   Breaking the missional Code
    Planting Missional Churches 11 Innocations in the Local Church   Spiritual Warfare and Missions
    Mission Shift Lost and Found   Viral Churches
    Small Group Resources

    Install Flash

    Get Adobe Flash player

    Schools Where I Teach
    Compelled by Love
    Ministry Partnerships
    Christianity Today Outreach magazine
    Catalyst Monthly Facts and Trends
    Christian Post
    imb connecting Baptist Center
    LifeWay: Research - Biblical Solutions for Life
    LifeWay: Biblical Solutions for Life
    Noteworthy Items
    Noteworthy Items
    • The Awesomeness-Driven Church
    • Bill Hybels on Leadership Fundamentals
    • When Preaching, Don’t Assume People Care What You’re Saying
    • A Good Word on Technology and Information
    • Two Christian Families in Bangladesh Suffer Extortion, Beatings
    • When sex offenders go to church
    • The Nature of Conversion, Then and Now
    • Ed Stetzer interviews me on unpaid Christian leadership